Without any more hesitation, she wrapped her lips around his meat, massaging the tip with her tongue. Evan sighed, placing his hand gently on the back of her head encouragingly. Rachel came out of her shell, drooling on his shaft, sporadically deep-throating as much of him as she could with her hands on his thighs. The sloppy sounds of her sucking were music to his ears along with her moaning more than he was; she really did want to suck his cock, he realized. Neither had noticed nor cared that the door to the apartment was still wide open while she fellated him a few feet away.
After however long, Evan was as hard and wet as he could be. She gave him one final lick before standing.
“I want you to fuck me like I’ve never been fucked,” she urged him, untying her bikini bottoms and dropping them to the floor.
“I’ll do everything in my power,” he assured her.
They kissed as Evan directed her with his hands on her hips towards the couch. When they stopped, Rachel turned around, climbing over the couch into the doggy position. She smiled mischievously back, bobbing her ass at him in case he needed more convincing. Evan wasted no time dropping to his knees, devouring her little peach like a starved man.
“Oh fuck, I was so hoping you’d do that, mmm,” she purred.
Evan felt the same as her, wanting to make her feel as good as he could. He would never see her again after the next day, but he derived a strange pleasure at giving a girl a hopefully memorable experience. Evan could not hold back a prideful grin at how she screamed when he sucked on her clit for the first time. She pushed back into his face, hinting for him to tongue fuck her; he did. Rachel giggled and squealed whenever his tongue traveled up, circling her ass, another thing she wouldn’t have let anyone else do.
“Please, fuck me, Evan. I need you,” she begged him.
Silently, he stood and aimed his pole at her opening.
Momentarily she wondered if he would even fit inside her but she shook the thought deciding that she’d make it fit. She didn’t need to tell him to go easy, knowing she was in very good hands. He eased the tip against her until it popped in causing Rachel to take in a deep breath. Freezing, he waited for the go-ahead to venture deeper. When she nodded, he pushed all but one inch of his length into her opening in one long, slow stroke.
“Fuuuuck…I’ve never felt so full,” Rachel said happily.
“You’re so tight,” he commented, gently easing in and out.
“You’re not exactly average size, you know,” she teased him. Evan grinned at her compliment.
After a couple minutes of getting used to him, she commanded, “Faster.” Evan complied, gripping her backside and finally starting to fuck her like she wanted. A continuous string of obscenities flew out of her mouth as Evan tried to hold in his laughter at the fact that she hadn’t said so much as ‘damn’ or ‘hell’ the entire day. The way she backed into his groin, trying to give as good as she got, rallied him on. At the sight of her creamy pussy making a mess on his cock, he knew the first round wouldn’t last much longer for him.
Across the yard, Jane stepped into her bedroom after the long Saturday shift. Pulling her work shirt and bra off was the highest priority. She opened the window facing the garage to feel the breeze against her bare chest, her new tradition, only to be treated to a view of Evan pounding away at Rachel bent over the couch. Only the shades facing the restaurant and parking lot were usually closed; Jane wondered if Mike’s warning of bedroom choice was due to Evan’s apparent exhibitionism. She rationalized that playing with herself while watching two hot people fuck was just so much better than porn, so she pulled her panties off.
Leaving on the short black skirt she bought just for work, she kicked off her sneakers and relocated the chair in her room to face out the window. Thankful that Evan faced away from her, she imagined it was just another sexy stranger as she ran her fingers between her lips. Masturbation had become a routine for her on the lake. She played before breakfast, after work at night, and sometimes even snuck off in the afternoon to cum anywhere she could get the privacy. The real live porn couldn’t have come at a better time as Jane was already soaked.
Rachel was super cute and she had admired Evan’s ass on a few occasions; never before that summer of course. The two of them together was just so needy and raw that it would be stupid to waste such a show.
Evan was fucking her as hard as he could and he needed to know what to do. “Where do you want me to cum?” he asked.
“Anywhere but…Inside me,” she huffed out, ready for a third and much bigger orgasm of her own.
Evan could feel the way she tensed up, gripping him tighter somehow. He picked up the pace, the tiny bit he had left, desperately trying to make her cum so he could too. She had stopped swearing only grunting or moaning then, completely lost in pleasure. Evan adjusted his angle in some way that caused the fat head of his dick to continuously bump into the most perfect spot inside her. Rachel felt as if she exploded into a thousand pieces as her orgasm rippled through her entire body.
“Fuck, fuck, FUCK!” she screamed as her fingers dug into the back of the couch. She resisted collapsing like she desperately needed to stay in position for him to finish.
He didn’t make her wait, pulling out, he said, “Yes!” blasting his cum all over her asshole and mound. It was a surprising feeling but definitely not an unpleasant one for her. She felt so naughty feeling him drip down her thighs, hoping he wasn’t finished with her for the night. When Evan finished sharing his load with her, he ran to get a towel and clean her off. Once she was spotless, she rolled over onto the couch, feigning exhaustion.
He smiled down at her, catching his own breath. “You can sleep here tonight if you want. I want you to I mean,” he told her.
She opened her eyes and asked, “I would love to spend the night, as long as you want me.”
“I want you, Rachel. If you’re up for it, two more times tonight and again in the morning?” he teased.
“Mhm, I’m game. We’d better get started,” she played along. Evan picked her up off the couch causing her to giggle. On the way to his bedroom, she admitted, “I’m never going to forget this day Evan. I want you to know that,” she said with a small amount of love in her eyes.
“That’s exactly what I was going for,” he said before kissing her and throwing her onto his bed.
Jane had had a small orgasm just from watching them both cum. It didn’t stop her from being highly irritated that they were taking it to another room that she couldn’t see into. Instead of ruining the mood, she closed her eyes to replay everything she had seen. Slipping her fingers inside, she drew circles around her clit with her other hand, getting right back into it.
At first, her reimagining had her joining in with them. Rachel ate her out while she watched Evan barrel into her from behind. She was grinding her pussy against Rachel’s face, pulling her head into her mound by her hair. She added a third finger to her wetness and as if some switch had been hit, Rachel disappeared and it was Evan fucking her. She could even hear the sounds of him slapping into her.
“Oh Evan,” she groaned out loud.
Her thoughts were a mess after that. “No, not Evan, you’re just friends. You don’t want him that way. You don’t…I don’t…Fuck, I don’t fucking care,” she thought.
“Yes, fucking Evan, fucking fuck me,” she squealed, at the onset of her own strong orgasm. Her fingers moved in a flash and she pressed directly on her clit to push herself even farther. The spasms folded her up in the chair with her knees near her head and her toes curled on the edge of the seat. As she came down, her knees would jerk back towards her chest occasionally, causing her to smile at the intensity of it all. Finally, she sat back in the chair like a lump, looking out at the star-filled sky.
She decided thinking about Evan fucking her in no way broke any rules. It was just the fact that he was off limits that turned her on so badly, that’s why she did it. Yes, she was attracted to him, but no good would come from doing anything more than fantasizing.
The following Tuesday Jane finally caved in. She needed to have sex, comfortable, familiar sex; with someone, she knew longer than a week. No more failed attempts to hook up with strangers. The time for pride was over, it would never happen again after anyway. At 2 O’clock in the afternoon, she texted Chad, to come up to the lake.
“We are never getting back together. I cannot forgive you for what you did to me & I will not. One time only offer tonight, you come to Newfound Lake in NH, sneak up to my room & fuck me…For the very last time. You tell no one or I will tell my brothers what you did.”
She didn’t want anyone to know how low she was about to sink, regretting the text immediately. He had texted her less as summer went on, which was exactly what she wanted by ignoring them all. Still, she wondered if he wasn’t going to post it online behind her back. He would make an even bigger fool of her than he already had.
“Anything, I miss you, babe,” he responded.